I’d mentioned previously how early Mennonites had a rough go of things – were often bullied out of their homes, and were pretty severely micromanaged even when they were allowed to stay. Now, it might seem obvious to assume that such a tumultuous and dangerous climate might lead one to strive for a somewhat modest and inconspicuous existence. Moreover, in addition to the risk, there were rules: in some communities Mennonites were only permitted to live and practice their faith under strict conditions. Their churches were built as unassuming structures on side streets, with no steeple to mark the location and no bell to call the service. Given the combination of legal restriction and limited means, churches were also lacking in the accoutrements so common to catholic cathedrals. The decoration was plain, minimal, and avoided drawing attention. The music was simple, choral, and served to remind members of their simple lives and history of persecution.
Outside the church walls, Mennonites continued to live with restricted liberty as well. As a result of frequently being required to give up possessions in order to retain individual freedoms, Mennonites learned to live very simply. To be quite blunt: you have less when you move a lot, especially when it’s by force.
Some branches of the modern church carried that 16th century simplicity to modern day living, which is why I mentioned the buggies at the beginning. Here, plainness is a virtue (as the opposite of ostentatiousness), based on the belief that a person's true worth does not lie in their clothes or appearance. But while some Amish, Hutterite, or Old-Order Mennonites lead a more austere existence, most denominations of Mennonites live fairly mainstream while retaining the same principles of humility and simplicity.
This comes not only from their history but also straight outta the good book itself: the principle of non-conformity as written by Paul, one of Jesus’ original 12. The concept of being “in the world but not of it” (more or less Romans 12:2) teaches people to lead a life that rises above petty concerns and is not pre-occupied with the trappings of a modern life.
BAM! A history of persecution and specific modesty-related restrictions combined with a doctrine of non-conformity to worldly ideals & standards gives you a humble individual who is not necessarily old-fashioned but remains unconcerned with keeping up appearances, who knows the value of a dollar having worked hard to earn it and is disinclined to spend it on frivolities. What’s not to like besides all the jokes about cheap Mennonites?
I could go on for ages about simplicity (and probably will, because
a) it’s a hot trending blog topic right now and
b) it is a defining aspect of the life behind this particular blog)
but it is imperative to note that in this context we are not strictly discussing simplicity with regards to fewer possessions, but rather as entire way of life that shears off all the excess and leaves you with an individual cognizant of a difficult history and grateful for their current existence. (I am by no means consistent on either count. So be it). And to learn that frugal and efficient are beautiful words, and that simplicity driven by humility is not a trend but a complete re-focusing of priorities.